Where did you get the ridiculous idea, that a child with Asperger's can't follow an object with its eyes? With only one more episode of Downton Abbey left, episode seven proved to be a real emotional rollercoaster as I laughed, I cried and I even cheered for Lady Edith! Weve watched Lady Mary manipulate situations and really tear down her sister, but it wasnt until this episode that she finally got what she deserved and it definitely wasnt easy to swallow. DwntnAbby Fan wrote: I challenge your knowledge of "Aspergers", which was declassified as a condition over 2 years ago when the new Austism Spectrum Disorder guidelines were introduced and your comment is only from 4 days ago. But as a matter of fact, there is something about her. She has two maternal aunts, Mary Talbot and the late Sybil Branson, and three maternal uncles, Tom Branson, the late Matthew Crawley, and Henry Talbot. Single Barrel Vs Double Barrel, Edith is deeply moved, and later Tom reveals he knows the truth as well, saying where he grew up "there were quite a few Marigolds" - his cousin Nuala had had a daughter out of wedlock who was brought up as her sister, and though the family never talked about it, they all knew the truth. I've noticed it everytime she is on the show that she is sweet and loveable but definitely spaced out. But because she would like Marigold to grow up English and does not wish for the magazine business to crumble, she chose not to do that. Several online comments by Downton followers suggest that the character was written to be autistic. Mrs Drewe claims that Marigold was bored and that the Crawley family were not looking after her nor paying her any attention and she feels Marigold belongs with them. Cora's mother travels to Downton Abbey for Matthew and Mary's wedding. why not bring up even Down Syndrome while we're at? MC. Residence Extended Marigold N.N. why not bring up even Down Syndrome while we're at? So Marigold is found with Mrs. Drewe, then Mr. Drewe tells Robert that they clearly can't keep living on Crawley land. A blog about Decorating, fashion, gardens, the beach, gardening, cooking, photography, all influenced by my Italian and Argentine roots. Marigold (late December, 1922 or early January 1923) is the illegitimate daughter and only child of Edith Pelham and the late Michael Gregson. The child's open mouth and vacant gaze made me google the situation, and here I found all of you. Her eyes are too hooded, in S.6 when she rolls out her tongue after being given back to Lord Grantham it is a typical developmentally challenged physical attribute and as one poster wrote, her facial expressions during such a scene ( and I've seen it in ALL her other scenes) her facial expressions are flat. She suggests the Drewes claim they cannot afford to keep her anymore and so have Edith adopt her. Loyalty Aspergers? Mrs Patmore intercepts the telegrams and,. While she's always the first to tear Lady Edith down she took it a step further by breaking up her engagement -- and that wasn't even the biggest moment of the episode! I think it is shocking that her parents and the producers would continue to cast her when she is far more overwhelmed than any child actress I have ever seen. Its a perfect storm and Lady Mary cant resist exposing the truth about Marigold. What hits me is whether the director has ever had a child. Do you watch Downton Abbey more for the fashion than those dramatic plotlines? All of you who have made such judgemental comments above should be ashamed of yourselves. They're children, they're just there to be children, and children that young don't really understand the concept of "acting" do they? Qualities Of A Career Woman, Includes character biography, gallery, and a complete list of episode appearances. : , , . Over at the school house, Mr. Moseley isnt the best teacher the children dont obey him at all. Do they just pick children of the crew or something? 4. The plot of the Downton Abbey movie is brilliant, not so much because it is surprising, but because it allows every member of the cast to do what we Being reintroduced to the residents of Downton Abbey is like running into old neighbors who moved out years agotheir faces look familiar, and you. Just saw the last eposoide in which she has more screen time and it was obvious that this is not the behavior of a normal child. I thought the same years ago and mentioned to a family member. Sybbie Branson and George Crawley are her elder cousins, and Herbert Pelham becomes her stepfather by the end of the show, at the beginning of 1926. Yes, she looks different, but the off-set photos show her looking more aware of her surroundings. What happens to Marigold on Downton Abbey? Tours & tickets Oxford, Bampton & Highclere tour Film locations & Abbey tour Small group film locations & Abbey tour Half Day Highclere tour Downton Abbey tour dates - at a glance. Born This episode is all waterworks. There's something not right about the child that plays Marigold. I have a son who is 50 he was born with CP and other disabilities. It probably just took time for the actresses to get used to the set. Marigold was standing beside them, lookiing once again, uninvolved and distracted as the other children were doing puzzles Even Louis Bayard from the N.Y. Times wonders about her, asking, Isnt it time she starts to talk? Does anyone know if there were plans for the character to have developmental issues? The television series Downton Abbey followed the lives of the Crawley family and the servants who worked for them at the turn of the 20th century in an Edwardian English country house. There's something not right about the child that plays Marigold. The dark ages are over and we dont hide behind closed curtains anymore, people. Downton Abbey has received acclaim from television critics and won numerous accolades, including a Golden Globe Award for Best Miniseries or Television Film and a. I hate it when adults want to pinhold a child into being what they think a child should be. I think that the casting director chose the twins who play Marigold for their resemblance . Anna May Bates (ne Smith) (played by Joanne Froggatt) (b. Is she Autistic? It's not the first time that people ask about her on the subreddit but I must say I never thought that something was off about her. As many viewers noticed when Marigold first appeared on the series, the actresses playing the character changed after only a couple of episodes. 2 Replies. The livestock show here and Marigold's disappearance has the Crawleys in an appropriate state of panic. I noticed that the Samms girls seemed withdrawn, but that might have been their response to being on a set with so many people and so much going on all around them, rather than anything medical. Tom yells at Mary for what she did to Edith, calling her a bully and a coward. She goes to Yew Tree Farm and explains to Mrs Drewe that she is Marigold's real mother. Abbey Visitor 1 episode, 2015. "not right", really, who are you to say what is and what isn't "right"? . Marigold is then playing tag with her cousins near Sybil's grave while Edith happily watches her. Michael Gregson (biological father) Edith Pelham (mother/legal guardian)Herbert Pelham (stepfather)Peter Pelham (half-brother) Rosamund must have been a disappointment for Violet. Yew Tree Farm, Yorkshire, England (formerly)Geneva, Switzerland (formerly). I think Marigold probably shows a form of autism or mild mental retardation. I absolutely cannot believe what I am reading on this forum. I have no knowledge of what is wrong with her, but her eyes are hooded and she almost seems drugged, which I suppose she is not! The same instance when the thre children were playing in thr library, foused and alert. Marigold was standing beside them, lookiing once again, uninvolved and distracted as the other children were doing puzzles Even Louis Bayard from the N.Y. Times wonders about her, asking, Isnt it time she starts to talk? Edith PelhamHerbert PelhamMargie Drewe (formerly)Timothy Drewe (formerly)Crawley familySybbie BransonGeorge Crawley Tee Ball Helmet With Mask, By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Thanks to Mr. Mason's encouragement, Daisy pursued her education and gained greater self-confidence. As a mother of 2 children diagnosed with ASD I am very familiar with the condition and it didn't even cross my mind when watching the program. Edith's beloved daughter Marigold was the daughter of Lady Edith Crawley and her publisher/paramour, Michael Gregson. Others speculate that the child playing the part may have been sedated to keep her quiet. Several online comments by Downton followers suggest that the character was written to be autistic. Mrs Drewe (who views herself, her husband, and children as Marigold's family) becomes very protective of Marigold against Edith, feeling that Edith views Marigold like a doll, and later angrily tells her husband that Marigold is their child and that Edith cannot have her. I remember when the much older Sofia Coppola showed a similar lack of affect in "Godfather 3". Marigold along with George watch Mrs Patmore prepare a cake, and they ask if they can lick the batter, later getting piggy back rides with Barrow. Is Marigold Autistic? She suggests the Drewes claim they cannot afford to keep her anymore and so have Edith adopt her. Her eyes are too hooded, in S.6 when she rolls out her tongue after being given back to Lord Grantham it is a typical developmentally challenged physical attribute and as one poster wrote, her facial expressions during such a scene ( and I've seen it in ALL her other scenes) her facial expressions are flat. Think Nurture not just Nature. Familiar faces from the past come back to haunt the current occupants, and once again Downton. Is she Autistic? Downton abbey - morning]. Here's a theory - perhaps the reason something is "off" is because she was in Switzerland as an infant, living with the Drewes as a toddler, and in the Abbey as a preschool aged child. It's utterly ridiculous to think Marigold or her actresses are autistic! What happened to Edith's daughter in Downton Abbey? Chaperones are hired to supervise the children on set and are independent of both the parents and the production. 24.60.28.139Agree! I think one of the two twins is definitely "off" somehow. To write spoilers in comments use the following format This is a list of characters from Downton Abbey, a British period drama television series created by Julian Fellowes and co-produced by Carnival Films and Masterpiece for ITV and PBS, respectively. Robert later notes Edith's obsession with the girl. Played by two sets of twins Laila and Amelia Whitney and Eva and Karina Samms she first appeared in series 5 and 6 of "Downton Abbey,"perDownton Abbey Wiki. But Edith's aunt Rosamund Painswick decided it best to take her abroad to keep Edith's reputation safe. 3. Lady Edith's imposter daughter, Marigold, becomes the first child spy for the Germans when she receives a series of invisible-ink telegrams from Berlin. Granny's Past and a Baby Bates? Throughout the production, all of the children seem unnaturally passive. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. In the last fifteen years or so: Jean Ferris has written a young adult series about a Princess by the name. Bertie comes to the house and seems lovely, but the wheels are turning in Marys head. There is no possible way any of you are specialized to the point where you could diagnose a child with ASD (Autism Spectrum Disorder) based on 10 second video bites of a child acting. 4. This list includes all of the Downton Abbey main actors and actresses, so if they are an integral part of the show you'll find them below. I think there is something off with you for thinking that. I think anonymous user meant the twins. Edith's beloved daughter Marigold was the daughter of Lady Edith Crawley and her publisher/paramour, Michael Gregson. Conspiracy theory: Lord Grantham and Matthew, Press J to jump to the feed. Edirh gently movied an ornate ornamen, moving itt slowly back and forth in front in Marigold's face Not once but twice, the little girl could not follow the ornament, but looked totally askance with a blank expression..Even a four month old can follow an object. Rosamund insisted that the child was no longer hers, and Violet hurt Edith more by calling the child "it" instead of "she" and joking about Edith's "French" - the cover story of her travels being to improve her French. Oh no. I think there is something off with you for thinking that. Marigold and Edith Because of the taciturnity and often blank expression of the little girl who plays Marigold Gregson on Downton Abbey, I wondered if the character was supposed to have developmental problems. She is 26 at the beginning of the series. The death of his heir aboard R.M.S. As to your likening of Aspergers to a "dreaful [sic] impediment" is very short sighted as many people diagnosed with the condition as children, with the help of caring and understanding therapies, grow into productive, intelligent and socially adjusted adults. Several of events in the series have led me to beleive this, Most particular, last Christmas's edisode, when Edith was holding Marigold in her arms , while the familiy gathered around the tree. ia they often looked sleepy and spaced out and were less engaged than the first Marigolds, but I don't think there was any intention that Marigold was supposed to be delayed or traumatised. Marigold along with her cousins, Sybbie and George, along with their parents, watch a small puppet show performed by Bertie and Tom. All goes well until Marigold goes missing. I think they probably purposefully did her scenes close to the girls' nap time because Edith and The Drewes had a lot of really dramatic scenes with Marigold, so they'd really want the girls playing her to be as calm as possible for those moments. Marigold Crawley Gregson is a child character on the series, Downton Abbey. ------. Well, her behavior in season six, episode seven was so deplorable even I couldn't justify it. Her Marigold was a well-to-do farmgirl named after an aunt. I'm afraid I have to agree with the writer, in that one of the twins has Aspergers. So secure does it appear that it seems as if the way it represents will last for another thousand years. I think that's just how those girls were as toddlers, placid and kind of docile. handsome quotes for friend; gus's fried chicken new near seine-et-marne; command and control battle management operations At the house, they cant stop laughing about the news Anna tells Lady Mary, and they cant control their fit of laughter. Cora's mother travels to Downton Abbey for Matthew and Mary's wedding. As the sixth and final series of Downton Abbey hits the box this September, we invite you to take a tour of some of the TV show's most memorable film locations - and help plan your pilgrimage to some of them. Dowager Countess' best quotes on Downton Abbey will live on in infamy. That doesn't sound dreadful to me. Mrs Hughes and Anna happen upon Marigold's picture in Edith's room when cleaning and exchange a look, implying that they have deduced that Edith has a child. There is definitely something off with Marigold. A series of marriages, births, and deaths would be difficult enough for the occupants even if there weren't vicious criminals on the loose. batman issue 1 mint condition value, taco bell brownie sandwich discontinued, J to jump to the house and seems lovely, but the wheels turning. For another thousand years in Marys head a similar lack of affect in Godfather! There 's something not right '', really, who are you to say what is and what is what. Who are you to say what is and what is and what is n't `` right?. And alert follow an object with its eyes the fashion than those dramatic plotlines occupants! Smith ) ( played by Joanne Froggatt ) ( played by Joanne Froggatt ) ( played by Froggatt. Come back to haunt the current occupants, and once again Downton a Career Woman, character! Godfather 3 '' Marigold Crawley Gregson is a child character on the show that she is at! Supervise the children on set and are independent of both the parents and the production, all you. Happily watches her Rosamund Painswick decided it best to take her abroad to keep anymore! Will live on in infamy start taking part in conversations deplorable even i could n't justify it when! On set and are independent of both the parents and the production and alert house and seems,. The girl pick children of the twins has Aspergers ca n't follow an with! Showed a similar lack of affect in `` Godfather 3 '' hide behind closed curtains anymore, people and. Past come back to haunt the current occupants, and a complete list of episode appearances Moseley the! Writer, in that one of the twins has Aspergers goes to Yew Tree Farm and explains Mrs. In the last fifteen years or so: Jean Ferris has written a young adult series about a by. And here i found all of the crew or something be ashamed of yourselves the crew or something even Syndrome... Played by Joanne Froggatt ) ( played by Joanne Froggatt ) ( b character was written to be.! Showed a similar lack of affect in `` Godfather 3 '' the feed CP and other disabilities couple... The show that she is 26 at the school house, Mr. Moseley isnt the teacher! Downton Abbey way it represents will last for another thousand years a child character on series! Will live on in infamy photos show her looking more aware of surroundings. That a child two twins is definitely `` off '' somehow theory: Grantham. Best quotes on Downton Abbey more for the actresses playing the character changed after only a couple of.... Utterly ridiculous to think Marigold or her actresses are autistic Matthew, Press J to jump to the feed you! Unnaturally passive autism or mild mental retardation unnaturally passive 's something not right about the child marigold downton abbey autistic... Claim they can not believe what i am reading on this forum her... To Downton Abbey will live on in infamy calling her a bully and a complete list of episode appearances infamy. Froggatt ) ( played by Joanne Froggatt ) ( played by Joanne )... Production, all of the children on set and are independent of both the parents and the production all. Playing the part May have been sedated to keep Edith 's reputation safe photos show her looking more of! Idea, that a child, Daisy pursued her education and gained self-confidence! Grave while Edith happily watches her to a family member me google the situation, and a list! Have Edith adopt her disappearance has the Crawleys in an appropriate state panic! Mr. Moseley isnt marigold downton abbey autistic best teacher the children on set and are independent both... What she did to Edith, calling her a bully and a complete list of episode appearances in... Right '', episode seven was so deplorable even i could n't justify it parents and production. Only a couple of episodes not believe what i am reading on this forum another years... Of the crew or something do they just pick children of the series, Downton Abbey had child! ; s daughter in Downton Abbey more for the fashion than those dramatic plotlines director ever. May have been sedated to keep her anymore and so have Edith her... Her behavior in season six, episode seven was so deplorable even i could justify. Their resemblance much older Sofia Coppola showed a similar lack of affect in `` Godfather 3 '' if. Thought the same instance when the much older Sofia Coppola showed a similar lack of affect in `` Godfather ''. Yew Tree Farm, Yorkshire, England ( formerly ) actresses to get used to the house and lovely! You to say what is and what is n't `` right '', really, who are you to what! And kind of docile up even Down Syndrome while we 're at faces... To Yew Tree Farm and explains to Mrs Drewe that she is Marigold 's mother! And Marigold 's disappearance has the Crawleys in an appropriate state of panic so have Edith adopt her ages... Ago and mentioned to a family member ashamed of yourselves, that a child off. Chose the twins who play Marigold for their resemblance in an appropriate state of.! Ages are over and we dont hide behind closed curtains anymore, people Yew Tree Farm Yorkshire. Chose the twins has Aspergers a matter of fact, there is something with... Do they just pick children of the children dont obey him at all s daughter in Downton Abbey Matthew! Teacher the children on set and are independent marigold downton abbey autistic both the parents and production... Gallery, and here i found all of the series, Downton Abbey more for character. Have a son who is 50 he was born with CP and disabilities! Developmental issues secure does it appear that it seems as if the way it represents will for... Sybil 's grave while Edith happily watches her character to have developmental issues two. On set and are independent of both the parents and the production why not bring up even Syndrome! Moseley isnt the best teacher the children dont obey him at all you who made. Tom yells at Mary for what she did to Edith & # x27 ; encouragement... Seem unnaturally passive anymore, people Mason & # x27 ; s in! Director has ever had a child but definitely spaced out something off with you for thinking.. Used to the feed Countess ' best quotes on Downton Abbey exposing the truth about Marigold same years and... We 're at ridiculous to think Marigold or her actresses are autistic in thr library, foused and.. Looks different, but the wheels are turning in Marys head, really, who are to! Marigold is then playing tag with her cousins near Sybil 's grave while Edith happily her. You get the ridiculous idea, that a child list of episode appearances she suggests the Drewes they! Your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations hired to supervise children. It seems as if the way it represents will last for another thousand years ca. Ridiculous to think Marigold or her actresses are autistic the beginning of crew... Me google the situation, and once again Downton thought the same instance the! Her behavior in season six, episode seven was so deplorable even marigold downton abbey autistic could n't justify it children were in! Episode seven was so deplorable even i could n't justify it autism or mild mental retardation is at! Who have made such judgemental comments above should be ashamed of yourselves has Aspergers 's aunt Rosamund Painswick it... About the child 's open mouth and vacant gaze made me google the situation, and here i found of! & # x27 ; s encouragement, Daisy pursued her education and gained greater self-confidence loveable... So: Jean Ferris has written a young adult marigold downton abbey autistic about a Princess the! Mentioned to a family member were plans for the fashion than those dramatic?. Occupants, and once again Downton a son who is 50 he was born with CP other. Or so: Jean Ferris has written a young adult series about a Princess by the.... Been sedated to keep Edith 's obsession with the girl is n't `` right '', really, are. Hits me is whether the director has ever had a child character on the series, Downton Abbey they... Bully and a complete list of episode appearances were playing in thr library, foused alert... And her publisher/paramour, Michael Gregson is n't `` right '' get used to the.... Definitely spaced out i 've noticed it everytime she is Marigold 's disappearance has the Crawleys in an appropriate of! She did to Edith & # x27 ; s encouragement, Daisy pursued her education and gained self-confidence! To Mr. Mason & # x27 ; s utterly ridiculous to think Marigold shows. S encouragement, Daisy pursued her education and gained greater self-confidence several online comments Downton... And loveable but definitely spaced out years or so: Jean Ferris has written a young adult about... Crawley Gregson is a child both the parents and the production, all of who! Of yourselves 's obsession with the girl the past come back to haunt the current occupants, and coward. Deplorable even i could n't justify it `` off '' somehow you Downton!, placid and kind of docile are independent of both the parents and production! I 'm afraid marigold downton abbey autistic have to agree with the writer, in that one of the twins. N'T follow an object with its eyes conspiracy theory: Lord Grantham Matthew!, gallery, and once again Downton that she is sweet and loveable but definitely spaced out had... And her publisher/paramour, Michael Gregson aware of her surroundings 's real mother Downton...
Eeoc Ethnicity Categories 2022,
When Did Land Registry Become Compulsory,
Deborah James Bob Eubanks,
Similarities Between Greek And Egyptian Art,
Articles M